Skip to main content

Table 1 Overview of the methods with the best analytical performance for the detection of miRNA, ctDNA, CTCs and exosomes using various nanoparticles/nanomaterials

From: Nanotechnology in emerging liquid biopsy applications

Nanoparticles

Lowest limit of detection (LOD)/Method used

miRNA

ctDNA

CTCs

Exosomes

Gold nanoparticles

0.33 aM, 1 aM—0.1 nM graphdiyne decorated with AuNPs photoelectrochemistry

6.8 aM, 10 aM—10 pM

DSN amplification electrochemistry

single-molecule detection, SPR

100 aM, 0.1–10 fM

PCR amplification

lateral flow assay

10 CTCs (10 cells/mL)

10–100 cells/mL

RCA amplification

ICP-MS

32 exosomes/μL

1.25 × 105–1.25 × 109 exosomes/mL

SERS

Graphene oxide

10 aM, 50 aM–5 fM

DSN amplification

pulse voltametry

–

2CTCs/4 mL, immunostaining

50 exosomes/μL

106–109 exosomes/mL

fluorescence

Other carbon nanomaterials

0.1 aM, 0.15–20 aM

 + AuNPs, fluorescence

0.3 aM, 1 aM–0.1 μM

 + MnO2 nanosheets fluorescence

0.3 fM, 10 fM–1 nM

RNase HII amplification

SWCNTs, SERS

2 CTCs (20 cells/mL)

102–106 cells/mL

electrochemiluminescence

5.2 × 105 exosomes/μL

1.84 × 109–2.21 × 1010 exosomes/mL

colorimetric

Quantum dots

17 aM, 50 aM–50 pM

DSN amplification photoelectrochemistry

–

1 CTC, fluorescence microscopy

1 CTC, fluorescence (QDs-magnetic NPs)

100 exosomes/μL

105—1010 exosomes/mL

stripping voltametry

Copper nanoparticles

10 aM, 0.1 fM–10 pM

HCR, SDA and T7 exonuclease amplification

electrochemistry

–

–

4.8 × 104 exosomes/μL

7.5 × 107–1.5 × 1010 exosomes/mL

fluorescence

Silver nanoparticles

1 aM, 1 aM–1 nM

Au/Ag nanocube, LSPR

40.4 aM, 1 fM–1 μM

HCR amplification

SERS

1 CTC/2 μL (6 cells/mL)

50–105 cells/mL

Chriplasmonic

1 CTC/mL

10–103 cells/mL

Ag-iron oxide NPs, SERS

1 exosome/2 μL

5.4 × 102–2.7 × 1010 exosomes/mL

SERS

Magnetic (iron) nanoparticles

10 aM, 10 aM–10 nM

gold-coated magnetic nanoparticles

electrochemistry

-

1 CTC/mL

1–500 cells/mL

SERS

100 exosomes, magnetic resonance imaging

Silica nanoparticles

30 fM, 0.9–10 pM electrochemistry

-

–

–

Molybdenium disulfide nanomaterials

30 aM, 0.1 fM–10 nM

field-effect transistor

18 aM, 0.1 fM–0.1 nM

electrochemistry

–

–

Metal–organic frameworks

350 aM, 1 fM–10 nM

AuNPs-MOFs

SDA amplification

electrochemistry

–

–

–

Polymer nanoparticles

17 aM, 50 aM–100 pM

polyfluorene polymer nanoparticles

electrochemiluminescence

–

–

37.5 exosomes/mL

0.18–3.0 × 106 exosomes/mL

cationic lipid-polymer nanoparticles

fluorescence

Other nanoparticles

    

Tungsten diselenide nanosheets

60 aM, 0.1 fM–100 pM

DSN amplification

electrochemistry

–

–

–

ZnO nanostars

18.6 aM, 100 aM–100 pM

electrochemiluminescence

–

–

–

Bismuth nanoparticles

–

–

100 CTCs/mL

102–105 cells/mL

X-rays

–