Skip to main content

Table 5 The ASSURED-related claims and MORE-related issues in nanobiosensor research

From: Advances in nanobiosensors during the COVID-19 pandemic and future perspectives for the post-COVID era

ID

ASSURE-related claims

MORE-related Issues

Note

Platform

Sample preparation

Sensing performance

Measurement

Confrontation ability to evolving situation

Smart features

Global distribution

Low-cost

Disposable

Self-collection

Low volume

Rapid

Reproducible

Non-buffer environment

Portable equipment

Multiple antigen Detection

Antibody detection

Variant

Other viruses

Data transmission

Mass testing

Stability

Reusability

A01

    

           

[82]

A02

    

30 min

 

Untreated

Saliva

Portable

Potentiostat

S1 + N

       

[83]

A03

    

 

Lysis Buffer

Portable

Potentiostat

S1 + N

       

[84]

A04

     

        

 

[85]

A05

  

 

  

Portable

Potentiostat

    

Bluetooth

   

[86]

A06

   

[Saliva]

5 min

[OP]

35 min

 

Saliva

       

42 Days

Twice More

[87]

A07

   

 

Saliva

Portable

Potentiostat

      

4 Weeks

 

[88]

A08

    

 

      

30 Days

 

[89]

A09

 

   

Diluted Saliva

       

5 Days

 

[90]

A10

     

        

35 Days

 

[91]

A11

    

30 min

 

   

INF A (H1N1)

  

7 Weeks

(at 25℃)

30 Times

[92]

A12

    

2 h

        

10 Days

 

[93]

A13

    

  

        

[94]

A14

    

         

21 Days

(at 4℃)

5 Times

[95]

A15

   

  

Portable

Potentiostat

    

WiFi

   

[96]

A16

    

  

Portable

Potentiostat

  

Alpha

Beta

Delta

 

Wireless

   

[97]

A17

   

           

[98]

A18

   

           

[99]

A19

   

        

[96]

B01

   

          

[101]

B02

    

45 min

  

Portable

Potentiostat

        

[102]

B03

     

Diluted Saliva

Miniaturized

EC cell

        

[75]

B04

   

        

10 Days

(at 4℃)

 

[103]

B05

   

35 min

        

30 Days

 

[104]

B06

   

6.5 min

 

  

Beta

   

7 Days

(at 4℃)

 

[105]

B07

    

           

[106]

B08

   

          

[107]

B09

   

15 min

 

Portable

Potentiostat

  

     

[108]

B10

    

30 min

         

21 Days

 

[109]

B11

   

45 min

     

Omicron

     

[110]

B12

   

 

Hand-held Portable

Potentiostat

      

9 Times

[111]

B13

 

  

 

Portable

Potentiostat

      

15 Days

 

[112] 12/9/2023 1:19:00 PM

C01

   

           

[113]

C02

    

         

9 Months

(at 4℃)

 

[114]

C03

  

      

INF A (H1N1)

    

[115]

C04

   

 < 60 min

 

Serum and Diluted Serum

Portable

Potentiostat

    

Smartphone

   

[116]

C05

                

[117]

C06

  

20 uL

70 min

  

Portable

Potentiostat

  

Alpha

Beta

     

[118]

C07

   

 

    

Smartphone

 

20 Days

(at 4℃)

 

[119]

C08

 

 

 

Portable

Potentiostat

      

3 Days

  

D01

    

           

[121]

D04

    

Saliva

         

[124]

E01

  

20 min

        

14 Days

 

[125]

E02

 

 

        

  

[126]

E03

   

1 uL

21 min

           

[127]

E04

    

           

[128]

E05

 

4 min

VTM and

Saliva

Handheld

Potentiostat

  

Alpha

 

Smartphone

 

10 Days

(at 25℃)

 

[76]

E06

 

 

           

[129]

E07

   

        

7 Weeks

(at 4℃)

5 Times

[130]

E08

   

         

21 Days

 

[131]

E09

   

Diluted Saliva

       

10 Days

[132]

E10

    

        

4 Weeks

 

[7]

E11

   

15 min

 

Portable

Potentiostat

        

[133]

E12

   

    

Alpha

     

[134]

E13

               

[135]

E14

   

           

[136]

E15

  

           

[74]

E16

   

         

10 Times

[137]

E17

   

30 min

 

Portable

Bi-Potentiostat

  

Alpha

 

Wireless

 

 

[77]

E18

              

6 Weeks

4 Times

[138]

E19

    

15 min

    

Alpha

   

30 Days

 

[139]

E20

 

10 uL

35 min

 

        

[140]

E21

    

     

Alpha

Beta

Delta

     

[141]

E22

 

  

40 min

 

Portable Electrical Readers

        

[142]

E23

   

10 min

 

Portable

Bi-Potentiostat

  

 

WiFi

   

[143]

E24

              

 > 30 Times

[144]

E25

   

        

14 Days

  

E26

   

        

3 Weeks

[145, 146]

E27

   

 

Portable

Potentiostat

      

20 Days

 

[147]

E28

    

          

[148]

E29

  

          

[120]

E30

   

           

[149]

E31

   

  

  

Alpha

Delta

     

[150]

F01

 

 

5 uL

15 min

 

Saliva

Hand-held Reader

        

[151]

F02

         

Anti-S1 Antibody

      

[152]

G01

   

           

[153]

G02

    

          

[154]

G03

    

        

3 Weeks

 

[155]

G04

   

30 min

        

21 Days

 

[156]

G05

     

        

 

[154]

H01

                

[158]

H02

    

 

Diluted VTM

         

[159]

H03

   

   

S1 + N

       

[43]

H04

   

      

INF A (H1N1)

    

[160]

H05

    

           

[161]

H06

   

20 min

    

Anti-S1 Antibody

      

[162]

H08

   

         

5 Times

[164]

H09

        

S1 + N

       

[165]

H10

   

 

Portable Integrated Platform

      

228 Hours

(at 4℃)

 

[73]

H11

    

20 min

  

Portable FET Sensor

  

Delta Plus

Kappa

     

[166]

H12

    

20 min

           

[167]

H13

 

  

30 min

 

Artificial

Saliva

Portable Reader

    

Bluetooth

   

[168]

H14

    

 

Portable Reader

    

Bluetooth

   

[169]

H15

    

           

[170]

H16

    

 

Saliva-relevant Fluids

         

[171]

H17

    

20 min

  

Portable Reader

S1 + N

 

N501Y, D614G, Y453F, Omicron-B1.1.529

 

Wireless

   

[172]

H18

    

 

Home-built Portable Readout Electronic Unit

 

Anti-S1 Antibody

    

 

[173]

H19

   

         

6 Weeks

 

[174]

I01

   

        

10 Days

2 Times

[175]

I02

    

           

[176]

I03

  

  

Biopotentiostat

  

Alpha

    

Multiple Times

[177]

I04

    

        

7 Days

(at 4℃)

 

[178]

I05

   

1 h

           

[179]

I06

   

      

INF A

    

[180]

J01

    

           

[62]

J02

  

   

S1 + N

       

[181]

J03

   

   

S1 + N

     

6 Days

 

[182]

J04

               

[183]

J05

  

25 min

  

  

 

Bluetooth

 

15 Days

 

[184]

J06

                

[185]

J07

                

[186]

K01

   

16 min

  

    

   

[187]

K02

   

        

30 Days

 

[188]

L01

    

           

[189]

L02

    

           

[190]

L03

    

75 min

           

[191]

L04

    

           

[192]

L05

    

           

[193]

L06

    

        

21 Days

6 Times

[194]

L07

    

  

Portable SPR

  

Alpha

Beta

Delta

Omicron

     

[195]

M01

    

           

[196]

M02

   

20 min

  

Portable

UV–Vis spectrophotometer

   

CoV-NL63

    

[197]

M03

  

30 min

 

Diluted Serum

Portable Reader

  

Alpha

Beta

Gamma

   

30 Days

 

[198]

N01

   

           

[199]

N02

   

           

[200]

N03

     

Serum

         

[63]

N04

   

  

      

14 Days

Once More

[201]

N05

  

  

Portable Microplate Readers

    

Smartphone

   

[63]

N06

    

         

14 Days

 

[201]

O01

   

           

[69]

O02

     

Saliva, Serum, and Blood

       

15 Days

 

[204]

O03

       

S1 + N

       

[205]

O04

   

          

[206]

O05

    

           

[207]

O06

    

           

[208]

O07

    

15 min

 

Mixed Protein Solution, Urine, Blood

Portable Raman Spectrometer

        

[209]

O08

    

30 min

  

Portable Device

        

[210]

O09

    

 

Cell Lysate

         

[211]

O10

    

30 min

  

Handheld, Battery-Operated Device

  

Alpha

Beta

Delta

HKU1

    

[212]

O11

    

           

[213]

O12

          

N501Y

E484K

T478K

     

[214]

P01

   

      

Smartphone

 

7 Days

(at 4℃)

4 Days

(at RT)

 

[215]

P02

    

           

[216]

P03

             

35 Days

(at 4℃, RT, 37℃)

 

[217]

Q01

    

50 min

           

[218]

Q02

    

 

Artificial

Saliva

         

[219]

R01

   

     

Alpha

   

15 Days

 

[220]

S01

   

  

Portable MPS Systems

        

[221]

T01

 

 ~ 15 min

     

Alpha

   

 

[222]

U01

   

    

14 Days

 

[223]

U02

    

           

[224]

U03

  

        

4 Weeks

(at 4℃)

 

[225]

U04

    

20 min

  

Portable Raman Spectrometer

        

[226]

U05

   

           

[227]

U06

  

            

[228]